In the mattress industry, when you talk about Casper and Tempur-Pedic, you’d know that these two brands are reputable companies, which have spent years, producing quality models of outstanding mattresses. Tempur-Pedic’s astounding achievement and established reputation are owing to the high-quality foams, especially memory foam, which it uses to deliver exceptional mattresses for unique mattress-sleep experience for users. Casper, on the other hand, some few years back, abruptly came into the picture with its sophisticated bed-in-a-box mattress models, which is delivered right at your doorstep. All Casper’s services, plus the mattress’s quality, are offered at affordable and market-competitive prices.
There are many mattress models from Tempur-Pedic. These models include all-foam mattresses, as well as hybrid beds, which use innerspring support cores. Irrespective of their construction, all these models from Tempur-Pedic share one feature, that is, the use of memory foam in their comfort layer. Likewise, Casper has three models of mattresses behind its name; the original Casper, the Essential, and the Wave. However, for this article, we are only going to focus on their most established model, the Casper.
With the popularity and recognition that these two brands have gained, it is common for any shopper to want it to be easier to compare and choose one between them. For this reason, we, in this guide, will show you the similarities and dissimilarities between the Tempur-Pedic and the Casper, as well as the measures you need to take to decide the one that will suit you best.
The research done on this website is made possible by commissions earned through sales from affiliate links shared within the content. Learn more here.
Casper and Tempur-Pedic Comparison
- When you visit Tempur-Pedic’s and Casper’s website, perhaps the first thing that you will observe is that both brands put loads of mattresses up for sale.
- While Tempur-Pedic sells above a dozen of beds, Casper sells just three.
- Both Casper and Tempur-Pedic principally sell all-foam mattresses.
- Although Tempur-Pedic sells some hybrid mattresses with foam and pocket coils, they mostly trade in all-foam mattresses.
- All three models of bed from Casper are all-foam.
- Even though there are little detailed differences between both companies’ policies, both Casper and Tempur-Pedic offer free shipping policies. However, customers living in the continental US get free-of-charge delivery offers from both Tempur-Pedic and Casper.
- Both companies have incredibly similar terms of sale.
- Both companies come with trial periods. However, while you get to try a Casper at home for 100 nights, the trial period for a Tempur-Pedic mattress is 90 days. Nevertheless, both companies offer a 10-years warranty lest you decide to keep the bed.
- Both companies also provide completely-free returns.
- The most significant differentiating factor between Casper and Tempur-Pedic is their price points.
- While Casper mattresses are affordable, Tempur-Pedic beds are luxurious, and therefore, rather expensive.
- The Casper Wave is the only Casper’s product, which costs as much as Tempur-Pedic’s least-priced mattress.
- The type of beds the companies produce is also another differentiating-factor between these two brands.
- While Tempur-Pedic offers a more flexible set with memory foam and hybrids, Casper has only all-foam mattresses.
- Subsequently, you will need to extend your search if you need a pocket coil mattress with an affordable price point.
- Several other factors set the Casper aside from the Tempur-Pedic. Such factors deal with stuff like return policies, shipping, and delivery, etc., which we are going to discuss in the full comparison section below.
Mattress Construction Comparison
Although there are similarities in some of the materials in the Original Casper and Tempur-Pedic mattress, there are several differences, which set the performances of the beds aside.
The original Casper is an all-foam, 8.5-inch-tall 4-layered mattress. It comes with a basic-polyester cover.
- In the top layer is a 1.5-inch thick layer of specialty polyfoam. This layer incorporates an open-cell structure, which controls heat retention. Since the composition of this layer has proportions of latex and memory foam, it is designed to provide enough resilience and bounce for the mattress. Thus, it does not only prevent your body from sinking into the bed, but it also possesses contouring abilities for sufficient pressure and pain relief.
- In the second layer is a 1.5-inch layer of memory foam, which allows for enhanced cushioning and contouring for better pressure relief.
- In the third layer is a 1.5-inch-thick layer of transition polyfoam.
- Finally, the bottom layer is made of 4 inches of supportive polyfoam.
- Casper does not disclose the comprehensive technical specifications, e.g., the ILD or density, of these materials.
There are three major product lines for Tempur-Pedic, which are Cloud, Contour, and Flex. While the Cloud and Contour lines are for the all-foam models, the Flex is a hybrid line.
- The topmost layer in the Cloud and Contour mattresses is made of memory foam. Tempur-Pedic is not only one of the first ever-known companies for using this material, but it is also reputable for the excellent quality of memory foams that it uses for perfect contouring during sleep.
- After the memory foam layer is a polyfoam layer, which is the base of the comfort layer in the mattress. As there are more than ten models of mattresses produced under this Cloud and Contour collection, quite evidently, there will be significant differences between these mattresses’ heights, as well as the thicknesses of their comfort layers.
- Tempur-Pedic also makes use of memory foam in the comfort layer of the beds in the Flex product line. However, different from the all-foam mattresses’ comfort layer, a pocketed innerspring-coil foundation follows the comfort layers of these mattresses. As these pocketed coils give the bed extra responsiveness and superior bounce, these models are bouncier than all the all-foam mattresses from Tempur-Pedic.
The Tempur-Pedic, like the Casper, does not let out any specific information about their mattresses. So, detailed specifications such as the thicknesses of the layers in their beds, or the ILD or density of the foams they use are a proprietary secret of the company.
As a part of the criteria for getting a mattress, it is essential to settle for a bed that will comfort you. Of course, if you want to enjoy many nights of relaxing sleep, you need to find a mattress that will suit your needs concerning softness or firmness of the bed. This attribute of softness and firmness is what is referred to as “the firmness of a mattress.” However, there is no general firmness level for every sleeper, as what you will find comfortable might feel too soft or too firm for another sleeper.
For a general scale-rating, we use a scale of 1-10 to rate firmness. As 1 is the “softest” rating, 10 is the rating for the firmest level at which any mattress can be. Although there are many mattresses with other firmness levels, the most common firmness level is between 4 and 7 on the scale. This level is generally known as the Medium-Firm.
For the original Casper model, there is only a single level of firmness, which is between 6 and 7 on the standard scale. Although this firmness level suits many sleepers, if you need a firmness level that is outside this range, the Casper is not exactly your choice. For Tempur-Pedic, on the other hand, since there are a bunch of mattress models in their collection, there are a whole lot of different firmness levels available for sleepers. For instance, the all-foam models from Tempur-Pedic come with a firmness rating between 3 and 8 on the scale, while their hybrid alternatives are rated between 4 and 6 on the scale. That being said, if you need a wide range of firmness choices to choose from, the Tempur-Pedic might be a better choice for you.
Concerning the sleep experience with any mattress user, we link this factor to a lot of factors, and this factor might be relevant to one person than it is to the other. So, even though there are some factors which make the Casper similar to the Tempur-Pedic, there are also other detailed dissimilarities that you might overlook. In the following fragments, we will look at some of these specific factors that set the Casper from the Tempur-Pedic.
When overheating occurs during sleep, it can dent the quality of sleep a person gets at night, and even disrupt the entire sleep of the person. The common cause of overheating is a situation whereby there is a blockage of air, or obstructed airflow around the body, which will cause heat to build up around the body. Overheating can also occur when a person uses a heat-trapping mattress to sleep at night.
In the past, there had been issues with Tempur-Pedic concerning overheating. The material in the mattress contours too closely to the body to the extent that it causes too much sink and excessive build-up of heat around the sleeper’s body. Besides, memory foam, by nature, retains heat and softens after some time. Thus, it causes more sink and initiates more heat retention. However, recently, Tempur-Pedic has made it public that they have made innovations and changes to their models, and so, their mattresses do not retain as much heat as they used to before.
Initially, the Casper doesn’t have issues with overheating, owing to its composition that makes it bouncier, and gives it less sink, when compared to traditional memory foams. Besides, the open-cell design that Casper adopted at the comfort layer does not promote heat retention. For these reasons, if you are keen on finding a mattress with excellent temperature control, you should pick the Casper over the Tempur-Pedic.
When a person moves on the surface on a mattress, some movements are felt by the other partner, who shares the bed with the person. Motion transfer refers to how much of this movement that the partner feels. A mattress is said to have functional motion-isolating abilities if one feels little of this movement.
In terms of the best mattresses for motion isolation, Tempur-Pedic is one on the list. They are known for their pinpointed-contouring memory foam, which is responsive only to the location of pressure application. So, with this feature, very little motion is transferred on a Tempur-Pedic mattress. However, the Casper also does a very great job at motion isolation. In fact, most sleepers enjoy its motion isolation. But, if you place significance over motion isolation, of course, Tempur-Pedic is your best bet.
Proper spinal alignment and health require proper cushioning for all the parts of the body. For a thorough distribution of cushioning to each body part, a responsive mattress does most of the supportive work. Such a mattress contours and cushions the body parts based on how much weight and pressure they place on the mattress’s surface.
In terms of responsiveness, both the Casper and Tempur-Pedic perform superbly. The Casper is responsive to body weight and useful for spinal and neck alignment due to the memory foam and open-cell polyfoam in the comfort layer. Conversely, the memory foam in the Tempur-Pedic does all the work, as it responds to the body weight of the sleeper, while it contours to the body and helps with spinal health and pressure relief. Nevertheless, since some customers find the Tempur-Pedic extremely contouring for their requirements, the Tempur-Pedic does not fit every user. Overall, although the Tempur-Pedic responds better than the Casper, both brands are beneficial for spine alignment in most sleepers.
Resilience and Bounce
Resilience in a mattress refers to a feature which allows the bed to bounce back to its original shape after applied pressure is taken off its surface. When a mattress does this faster, it is “bouncier.” Many consumers attach significance to this feature since it prevents that stuck-in-the-mattress feeling, and allows more effortless movement on the surface of the bed, making it less difficult to switch sleeping positions or have sex.
On a broad scale, the Casper is more resilient than the Tempur-Pedic mattress. Memory foam, by nature, is a contouring material, which has a deficient level of resilience. For this primary reason, people using memory foam find that movement on the mattress’s surface is strenuous. Besides, they also feel like they sink too deeply into their beds. Even though the Tempur-Pedic Flex mattresses, with the innerspring unit, will be bouncier than the all-foam Cloud and Contour lines, it is not as bouncy as the Casper.
When we talk about the Casper, Tempur-Pedic’s Cloud and Contour line and Tempur-Pedic’s Flex, it is only the Flex that offers edge support. While the other models are all-foam, the solid innerspring construction inside the Flex mattress makes supportive enough to provide adequate full-bodied support at the perimeter of the bed. When you sit or sleep at or close to the edges of the Casper’s or the Tempur-Pedic’s Cloud and Contour line mattress, you will face a deal of instability.
Off-gassing and Smell
You should expect some odor when you, for the first time, unwrap and any of the abovementioned models after delivery. As they are made of memory foam, they are bound to give off initial odor after they have been unpackaged. Mind you, this odor is harmless, and will only last a few hours if your room has adequate ventilation.
Casper vs. Tempur-Pedic: Huge Price Difference
When it concerns the purchase of a mattress, for several people, apart from the purchase of a house and a car, it is the most significant expenses in one’s budget. Likewise, for other people also, having to invest above $2000 on a mattress is the same as having to pay $150 on just one pizza; they aren’t saying the pizza is not extremely good, but, they’d also get a delicious pizza for $25. Well, we think both classes of people are correct, based on their circumstances. As you will be using your mattress for close to 8 to 12 years, you want to ensure that it provides enough support and comfort for you. Conversely, though, you will also get an excellent mattress for a much more affordable price. Overall, it owes to your situation and above all, individual preference.
Although the fixed price for a Casper queen is typically around $1,100, with a price cut or bonus, you can secure one with a price tag less than $1,100, based on the season and sale.
In the case of Tempur-Pedic, things are different. The company’s flagship, TEMPUR-Adapt line, is available as three varied models, with different prices. As of now, a TEMPUR-Adapt queen costs as much as $2,200. According to them, this value is “everyday value.” After this model is the collection’s mid-tier model, TEMPUR-ProAdapt with a cost of around $3,000. The final model in this series is their premier-grade model, the TEMPUR-LuxeAdapt. This model, currently, prices close to $4,000.
It is rather indisputable that irrespective of the Tempur-Pedic model you wish to choose, you are going to spend far more money on a Tempur-Pedic than a Casper.
For both companies, you get limited 10-year warranty coverage for repairs and defect-replacement. However, both companies are entitled to deciding whether repairs and replacements are required and if there are charges for shipping and handling, based on the circumstance.
You get a variety of sizes for every mattress type from both companies. Although some Tempur-Pedic models are not available in Twin or Twin XL, every model from both companies is available in Twin via California King.
Manufacturing and Customer Service
It is only customer service that makes a company lose formerly-loyal clients. It appears that both companies have highly-satisfactory customer service agents in the US. Notwithstanding, there hasn’t been any official announcement of the source of either of the company’s customer service agents.
Of all the memory foam mattress lines in the industry, Tempur-Pedic is the most well-known brand. Being in the mattress industry for more than 20 years has given them enough time to make their every line perfect. You’d quickly come across them in renowned mattress stores. You have enough time and opportunity to make thorough decisions before buying since they have a comprehensive website to guide you through your choices.
From their products o their customer service, this company is entirely successful. Surely, if you want to own a mattress that has a well-known name backing it, the Tempur-Pedic is what you need.
Conversely, Casper has not spent as much time in the industry; it has barely used ten years. Although, since they are kind of new, their durability is not entirely clear, it seems like most customers are satisfied with their products and customer service.
They established the company to eliminate mattress intermediaries. So, deciding to avoid distributors will produce, for you, a quality mattress with a lesser price point. Thus, the company, year after year, improves in terms of the reviews it gets from buyers.
Casper vs Tempur-Pedic – Which One Should You Choose?
If you have done some research, and after choosing the Casper and the Tempur-Pedic, you do not know which one to pick amongst the two, the following tips will guide you through your decision-making process.
Purchase the Casper if:
- You want more bounce: with the Casper, you will experience a bouncier surface, which facilitates more effortless movement on the bed.
- You do not like sleeping hot: The Casper sleeps cooler and retains less heat, due to its open-cell foam and less-sink feature.
- You are concerned with price and value: You should buy the Casper instead of the Tempur-Pedic, if you are price-conscious, as the Casper is reasonable less expensive.
- You prefer a Medium-Firm texture: as the Casper comes in only one firmness range, you should take this decision solely if you are sure that this firmness option will suit you without faults.
Purchase the Tempur-Pedic if:
- You prefer the best-known brand: in the mattress industry, Tempur-Pedic has established a solid foundation for its eminence and reliability today. This brand also represents celebrated innovators and early inventors and investors of memory foam. Ultimately, Tempur-Pedic is yours if you want a company with the broadest experience and strong track history.
- You want further buying alternatives: you will be best satisfied with Tempur-Pedic, owing to the diverse models of mattresses, which it has to offer.
- You add significance to contouring and motion isolation: the Tempur-Pedic is a better option for contouring and motion isolation, as the memory foam in the comfort layers provides more hug and contouring than you can ever imagine. This layer is also advantageous at motion isolation.
- You desire white-glove delivery: for a charge of $25 only, Tempur-Pedic offers white-glove delivery. With this service, a worker will install your new mattress and help you to take your old mattress away.
- You are prepared to invest hugely in a bed: even as the price point seems daunting, several buyers are still ready to spend a fortune on an expensive new mattress. If you fit into this group, then the Tempur-Pedic suits you better.
For Sleepers with Specific Needs
Now, down to those of you with specific needs, we still have you in mind.
- Side Sleepers: Choose Casper
Reason: With the excellent side support and zoned support layer in Casper’s mattresses, side sleepers do not have to strain their torso or exert pressure on their hips and shoulders.
- Stomach Sleepers: Choose Casper
Reason: As Casper is naturally medium-firm, stomach sleepers will find that it does not only keep the spine and shoulders aligned, but it also has enough edge support, which will prevent future occurrences of pain and discomfort.
- Back Pain: Choose Casper
Reason: of course, Tempur-Pedic also has back pain alternatives, but you have to add more than $1,000 to secure it. The design of Casper’s Wave is specifically built to improve the health of people who experience pain around their lower lumbar region. Besides, it is excellent at preventing tossing, a backache-worsening condition.
- Heavy People: Choose Tempur-Pedic
Reason: Casper just isn’t designed for heavy-weighted sleepers. Conversely, the Contour line form Tempur-Pedic provides extra support, and different from Casper, it doesn’t allow heavier individuals to sink in excessively. Thus, neither model is specifically for heavy sleepers. With the heavy-weighted individuals in mind, they offer a model for these sleepers and have a foundation for climate control to make available, extra cooling relief.
- Couples: Choose Casper
Reason: as Casper offers combinations, couples with different sleep likings will even enjoy this mattress better, as it incorporates more bounce for sex. However, if innerspring is your priority, then plunge into the Tempur-Pedic Flex. It is an excellent choice, although you will pay a lot much more.
Concerning total customer satisfaction, Casper and Tempur-Pedic have come this far with loyal customers and established reputations. Although the Tempur-Pedic has been in the industry with its quality and eminence for a longer time, it also comes with some downsides, such as its expensiveness, overheating, etc., that makes memory foam less satisfactory to customers.
Although the Casper is not as good for motion isolation and contouring, it comes with several benefits, as well as a generally affordable price point. In due course, it is evident that these two brands are worth deliberating upon. However, when you can compare these brands with your precedence, you can easily choose one that will suit you better.
You May Also Be Interested in the Next Posts on Our Website:
Novaform Mattress Review | King Koil Mattress Reviews | Tuft and Needle vs. Leesa | Tuft And Needle vs Casper | Leesa vs Casper | Helix vs Casper | GhostBed vs Purple | Sleep on Latex Reviews | Casper vs Purple | Denver Mattress Review | Tuft and Needle vs. Purple | Ghostbed vs. Casper | Hampton And Rhodes Mattress Review | Zinus Mattress Review | Tempurpedic Review | Stearns and Foster Mattress Review | Serta Mattress Review | Sealy Mattress Review | Tuft And Needle Review | Lucid Mattress Review | Purple Mattress Review | Nectar Mattress Review | Lull Mattress Review | Leesa Mattress Review | Casper Mattress Review | Beautyrest Mattress Review | Bear Mattress Review | Amerisleep Mattress Review | Ghostbed Review | Saatva Mattress Review | Layla Mattress Review