The research done on this website is made possible by commissions earned through sales from affiliate links shared within the content. Learn more here.
Since the sales of mattresses took a dominant presence online, several brands have taken advantage of this. Casper and Tuft & Needle are two of the companies at the top of the market. Casper holds a substantial part of the direct-to-consumer mattress market share through its effective marketing and advertising campaigns. Tuft & Needle, on the other hand, is going through steady growth and has invested heavily in innovative product development and strategic marketing.
These two mattress brands produce all-foam mattresses and are currently the most bought mattress brands by people looking to buy a new bed. The Tuft & Needle mattress falls within the low-cost bracket of products while Casper too is relatively affordable since the majority of customers can afford it anyway. If the price is the major determinant for you when buying a mattress, then you have your work cut out for you partly if you have to pick between these two brands.
Each of these mattress companies has other mattress models that they offer, but this review is about their flagship models. We will dig deep into the nitty-gritty of these options and make a comparison of how they perform so that you can be better informed when deciding which one you would like to buy.
Before we start discussing the differences between these two mattresses, let us have a look at what similarities they both share. What are the common things to both of them? You might be thinking this is odd, but we believe that knowing what they both have in common will better amplify the unique differences between each of the mattresses and will also lay the Tuft and Needle vs. Casper argument to rest.
- All-Foam: They are both all-foam constructions, but this does not mean they have the same feel. You will find a better explanation later on where you will see how each of the brands use 100% foam materials to produce a distinct feel and vibe.
- Bounce: This is another similar factor that they both share. Even though they both have an all-foam construction, they both feature layers in between them that brings some nice, springy lift to the mix.
- Availability of a variety of models: This is not peculiar to the mattresses we are reviewing, but it is worthy to note that the two brands sell different models of their mattresses. This way, they can cater to the need of a wide range of sleepers who have varying sleeping needs and preferences.
WHICH ONE SHOULD YOU BUY BETWEEN CASPER AND TUFT & NEEDLE MATTRESS?
Deciding on which of these two mattress brands is not an easy task. Each of them has its specific advantages as well as disadvantages and choosing the one that is right for you can become even more difficult. How about we help you out here?
You should buy the Tuft & Needle if any of the conditions below apply to you;
- You are on a budget
The Tuft & Needle is priced lower compared to the Casper, and it may interest you that this drop in price does not in any way impact its performance. It delivers an enjoyable sleep experience just the way you would like. If the price is the determining factor for you, then you should go for the Tuft & Needle.
- You want to know the specifications of the mattress you are buying
Tuft & Needle fully discloses all the details about its mattress from the density to the ILD of the foams. Casper does not give this information out, and this information could be valuable to customers who need some specific details to make their choice.
You should buy the Casper mattress if these conditions apply to you;
- You like mattresses with high contouring
The Casper mattress is highly responsive, and it delivered more hug to the body of the sleeper than the Tuft & Needle does. This contouring feature or ability provides the support and comfort that many sleepers need. If therefore, you love this kind of feel, then you should go for the Casper.
- You want the comfort layer to be made of memory foam
If you have used memory foam before and you like its feel, then you will love the Casper because 1.5 inches of its total height which is the comfort layer is made of memory foam.
Casper and Tuft & Needle have each sold their mattresses to thousands of customers, and these customers have reported their great experiences with the brands. They are both made from quality materials, durable construction, sleek design, and are priced competitively. These two mattresses are great options when you are in the market looking for a new mattress to help you sleep better.
COMPARING THE CASPER WITH THE TUFT & NEEDLE
Mostly, the differences between any two mattress brands are based on performance and durability. These two yardsticks are determined by how the mattresses are built. Although the two mattresses are entirely made of foam, there are some distinct differences in how they are designed. Here, we will look at the materials used to make both mattresses and their construction too.
TUFT & NEEDLE
The original Tuft & Needle mattress has a height of 10 inches which comprises of two interior foam layers and a smooth cover which is a blend of polyester and rayon to cover the mattress. Inside this mattress, the top layer is made using the Adaptive foam, which is a proprietary foam made by the company, and it is 3 inches thick. This proprietary foam has a density of 2.8 PCF, and it has conforming properties without hugging excessively or retaining heat. The bottom layer of the Tuft & Needle is a support polyfoam with a height of 7 inches and a density of 1.8 PCF.
The Casper mattress has a height of 8.5 inches, which comprises of four foam layers and covered using a polyester cover. The top layer of this mattress is an open-cell polyfoam layer of 1.5 inches, which means it has enough open spaces for air to go through. The second layer also has a thickness of of 1.5 inches, and it is made of memory foam.
The comfort layers are stacked so as to give the entire mattress contouring properties without having an excessive sink or heat buildup, which are typical of the comfort layers made of memory foam. Under the first two layers, the third layer has a thickness of 1.5 inches and is made of transition polyfoam while the bottom layer is made of a support polyfoam that has a height of 4 inches. Casper does not make the density of all these foam layers public.
COMPARING FIRMNESS LEVELS
The most important guiding factor when choosing a new mattress is checking how comfortable the mattress feels. If you care about getting good sleep, your bed should be a haven, a restful place, somewhere inviting and cozy that you can relax, fall into a deep sleep and wake up refreshed. The Firmness of a mattress is the major factor influencing comfort, and everyone has a preference for how hard or soft they want their mattress should be. So, there is no right or wrong firmness level; it is totally subjective and individual-dependent.
Usually, we rate firmness level on a scale of 1 - 10, where 10 is the highest firmness level (firmest) while 1 is the lowest level of firmness (softest). There are not many mattresses with firmness levels of 1 or 10 because not many people prefer mattresses with these extreme levels. The most common firmness levels in mattresses are somewhere between 1 and 10. Both the Casper and Tuft & Needle have a medium firmness level since they are both between 6 and 7 on the scale. Even though they feel similar, the Tuft & Needle mattresses are known to be higher on the firmness scale than the Casper.
PERFORMANCE AND SLEEP EXPERIENCE
Apart from the firmness of a mattress and how comfortable it makes you feel when you sleep on it, the performance of the mattress is another thing that you must put into consideration. Let’s check out some metrics for measuring mattress performance in this section.
Overheating is quite a common thing that many people experience when they sleep, and there are two reasons for that. First off, the mattress might be hugging to the body too closely, which leads to a deficiency of airflow around the body. Secondly, it could be as a result of the material used to make the mattress as some materials such as foam have high heat retention which leads to sleeping hot and can make you unable to sleep conveniently through the night.
The Tuft & Needle is less likely to cause overheating than Casper. This is because Tuft & Needle has a lesser hug and is firmer than Casper. It also promotes better airflow through it. Additionally, the proprietary Adaptive foam has gel and graphite built into it, which helps reduce the amount of heat the mattress retains. The Casper mattress also made an attempt at including features to help reduce heat retention with the open-cell foam, and to an extent, this works too. Not everyone who sleeps on Casper mattress complains of sleeping hot. But if sleeping hot is one of your major concerns, you would be making a better choice with the Tuft & Needle.
The Tuft & Needle and Casper mattresses have excellent motion isolation, which means that if two people are sleeping on the mattress, the movement of that person will not disturb the other person’s sleep. In other words, movement on one part of the bed is never transferred to another part of the bed.
This is an important feature for couples, especially if one of them is a restless sleeper who moves a lot in their sleep. Many couples will love either of these two mattresses just because of the motion isolation feature. In this regard, Casper is much better because it has enhanced contouring.
This is used to describe how well the mattress holds up against the weight of the body. By providing a cushion based on the weight of the body, a mattress that is responsive will keep the spine in proper alignment, and it will help protect the neck or back from any form of pain.
These mattresses have excellent responsiveness which adequately accommodates the pressure points in your body. The foams used in the two mattresses are designed to compress easily proportionately to the weight they are carrying. The Casper has more contouring and hugs better; therefore, people with sharp pressure points may prefer to buy the brand. But overall, the two mattresses deliver the same level of support.
BOUNCE AND RESILIENCE
When weight is applied to the foam, the result is compression after which it returns to its initial shape when the weight is off. If this happens fast without taking time, then it means that the foam has high resilience. This is what gives a mattress the springiness or bounciness you feel when you sleep on your mattress. This property also makes it easy for you to change your sleeping position without feeling stuck and to do just about anything on your mattress, including sexual activities. Between the Tuft & Needle and Casper, the Adaptive foam in Tuft & Needle has a lot more bounce than the Casper.
These two mattresses have little to no edge support, and you cannot sit on their edges without reinforced edges. If you try to sit close to the edge or even at the edge, you will feel the mattress giving out beneath you.
This is a common thing with every foam mattress when it is newly bought. After unboxing and unpacking the mattress, you will perceive a smell which takes some time to dissipate between a few hours and a few days. In both of these mattresses, the smell goes away within hours.
The Good Side of Tuft & Needle
Tuft & Needle has received quite some glowing reviews over the years, and all of these reviews point to a single fact – Tuft & Needle mattress delivers excellent value for money. Let us mention again that the Tuft & Needle mattress is not for people who are looking for top-of-the-line premium mattress models; it is for people who are looking for a balance between affordable and quality performance and when it comes to these, the company has achieved its goal.
Some of the positive feedback often point out:
- The excellent quality material used in manufacturing every Tuft & Needle mattress model.
- The superb customer support service before, during, and after the purchase.
- The construction and level of comfort the mattress delivers.
- The mattress works well for back sleepers, but side and stomach sleepers can also use it.
- The construction is solid enough to prevent back pain but soft enough to provide enough give to the weight of the body.
- It absorbs movement excellently, and it isolates movement on one side of the mattress from the other side.
- Its solid construction lends credence to its potential to be a long-term durable mattress.
Most of the feedbacks left by buyers showed that they found the Tuft & Needle mattress to deliver great value. Even though it is not in the league of premium model mattresses nor is it the cheapest mattress, it still remains one of those mattresses that deliver value, convenience, quality, and outstanding customer support service.
The Bad Sides of Tuft & Needle
We cannot have the good without expecting the bad. There were complaints about Tuft & Needle, but most of these complaints are about personal comfort levels which would have been discovered during testing. However, some other complaints stood out which have to be considered.
Some of the negative feedbacks point out the following:
- The bed feels firmer than what the company claims on its website.
- There is an odor associated with the mattress after unboxing it.
- Some customers mentioned that at night, the bed becomes hot.
- Some customers are allergic to the materials used to make the mattress, although this was not prevalent.
- The mattress is only good for sleeping and not comfortable for sitting or any other position other than sleeping.
- It has little to no edge support, especially for heavier sleepers.
- Some spots on the bed become soft after a few months of use.
- Only one side of the bed is usable.
Overall, the most common complaint that reviewers left is about the firmness of the complaint. As far as Tuft & Needle vs. Casper is concerned, the Casper may be a better choice for people who need a softer mattress.
VERDICT ON TUFT & NEEDLE
The reviews that Tuft & Needle has received so far show how many people find the mattress satisfactory enough for them. Numbers don’t lie, and the company itself ensures that it listens to whatever its customers are saying. So, best believe that the negative reviews and complaints will be dealt with and fixed as soon as possible.
Even more obviously, the company has been making adaptations and changes from the inception, and this has helped them produce an exceptional mattress. It may not be the best premium mattress ever made, but if you are stuck on the Tuft & Needle vs. Casper argument and you have to choose between the two, then you definitely are not looking for the best premium mattress. If that is what you want, a showroom should be your next stop.
Instead, what you are stuck with is an affordable, exceptional, and convenient that is easy to use and delivers great value for money. Even though some reviewers had complaints about the firmness, some other reviewers noted that Tuft & Needle is the perfect blend of comfort, firmness, and support. And as much as those who are not pleased with the firmness exist, there are those who are pleased with it and the percentage of those pleased with the firmness is a lot more than those who were not.
The Good Sides of Casper
If there is anything impressive that Casper has done for its customers apart from offering an affordable mattress, it is ensuring that the mattress is of high quality and the company itself offers excellent customer service. And by doing these, Casper is performing well. Many of their customers believe that the quality and comfort that Casper offered in its mattress could compete with established traditional mattress brands like Sleep Number and Tempur-Pedic.
Some of the positive features of Casper mattress are:
- Casper mattress is affordable. Made from quality materials and delivers good value to the buyer.
- The mattress has struck a balance between support and comfort.
- The mattress comes with a trial period of 100 days, including shipping and returns for free.
Below are some of the feedbacks that customers who have bought the Casper mattress left:
- The Casper mattress tends to conform well but not to the extent of sinking you into the mattress.
- Back and stomach sleepers can use this mattress and sometimes, side sleepers can sleep on it too if they are not too large.
- It is easy to set up.
- Absence of off-gassing after unboxing.
- Easy to set up using a box spring or any flat surface.
- Casper does not have the issue of getting hot even in summer.
- Customers have access to financing through Casper’s financing partner, Affirm.
- Casper can help with backache and pain if the mattress you are using presently is too soft.
- Many of the customers that had issues with the firmness of the Casper mattress got a mattress topper to make it softer.
- The Casper mattress does not need a topper at all times to provide comfort and support.
Overall, buying the Casper mattress is not so bad after all as most of the buyers mentioned that they were pleased with the product. Even those who expressed their displeasure mostly about the firmness received free mattress toppers if they made their complaints during the 100-night sleep trial period.
Casper also prides itself on excellent customer service to complement its impressive product. The main catch to Casper mattress is that it is not only a quality product; it is also affordable and gives value through comfort and support.
The Bad Sides of Casper
In all honesty, Casper does not have notable or a lot of bad reviews. Casper has ridden on the wave of its marketing message which says that its product is groundbreaking and innovative but being in an industry where a lot of competitors are trying to dominate the market, you can expect some disruptions. After checking through hundreds of customer feedback, some negative reviews stood out, and they addressed the following areas:
- Getting used to the Casper might take days or weeks if you were using a traditional mattress before.
- Only one side of the bed can be used.
- It cannot adequately support heavier sleepers, and it feels firmer for lightweight sleepers.
- Moving and transporting is hard as it does not come with side-handles.
- Some sleepers complained about “low spots” after using it for some time.
- It has poor edge support in comparison with traditional mattresses.
- It has a lean construction, thereby feeling a bit thinner than a traditional mattress.
- Some customer feels it does not do what its marketing hype says it does.
A few customers also noted that people with fibromyalgia should not use Casper. If you have fibromyalgia, we recommend that you seek medical advice first to know what kind of mattress is recommended for you.
VERDICT ON CASPER
To cap it all, Casper brings quality to the fore and has many above-average features as well as services with it, which includes free shipping and returns, excellent customer service and sleep trial of 100 nights. It is quite understandable that all that good stuff does not ensure that every customer will get a good sleep on the Casper, but Casper deserves the credit of being a pretty solid mattress.
Casper is a competitive brand, and they have one of the most effective marketing campaigns. They also have a clean and user-friendly website; therefore, it is safe to say that they are a strong force in the mattress industry. Casper is a good, affordable choice of mattress, and it saves you from walking into stores to deal with the confusion that salespeople project on you. You will not find the bells, frills, and whistles that some mattresses have but it is a perfect candidate for the Tuft & Needle vs. Casper argument.
WHO WINS THE TUFT & NEEDLE VS. CASPER ARGUMENT?
If nothing else is as important to you when buying a mattress as its price, then we recommend that you buy the Tuft & Needle. In fact, the Tuft & Needle trumps the Casper mattress in this Tuft & Needle vs. Casper debate in terms of price because Casper is more expensive than Tuft & Needle and it does not really have any significant edge over the Tuft & Needle in terms of performance and features.
They both have 100-night sleep trial, excellent customer service, warranties of 10 years, free shipping, and returns. So, for us, we did not spot any noticeable differences other than the fact that Tuft & Needle is based locally in the United States, is more affordable and all of the materials used in its construction are designed by their in-house research and development team.
If you look beyond price and consider overall support, comfort, features, and value, Tuft & Needle still wins hands-down. While Casper may have a brilliant business model, we just did not get blown away. They have been in the market for some years so they can make changes in the future, but right now, we choose the Tuft & Needle in this Tuft & Needle vs. Casper argument.
For these reasons, the Tuft & Needle wins this Tuft & Needle vs. Casper debate but if you ever buy any of these two mattresses, best believe that you will be buying a product that many people have bought, used and confirmed to be highly valuable and comfortable.
For Casper to become a top contender in the industry, we would like to see them come out with more mattress models that offer other levels of firmness and any other thing that makes it worth spending more than 20 percent more than the price of a Tuft & Needle mattress.
We hope that you have found this review helpful, especially with the fact that we made it be a Tuft & Needle vs. Casper debate. We also encourage you to carry out your own research and combine your findings with the information we have provided when deciding on a mattress model. Tell us if you run into any snags. We wish you Good luck in your mattress search and a good night’s sleep.
You May Also Be Interested in the Next Posts on Our Website:
Leesa vs Casper | Helix vs Casper | GhostBed vs Purple | Sleep on Latex Reviews | Casper vs Purple | Denver Mattress Review | Tuft and Needle vs. Purple | Ghostbed vs. Casper | Hampton And Rhodes Mattress Review | Zinus Mattress Review | Tempurpedic Review | Stearns and Foster Mattress Review | Serta Mattress Review | Sealy Mattress Review | Tuft And Needle Review | Lucid Mattress Review | Purple Mattress Review | Nectar Mattress Review | Lull Mattress Review | Leesa Mattress Review | Casper Mattress Review | Beautyrest Mattress Review | Bear Mattress Review | Amerisleep Mattress Review | Ghostbed Review | Saatva Mattress Review | Layla Mattress Review