The research done on this website is made possible by commissions earned through sales from affiliate links shared within the content. Learn more here.

Shopping for a new mattress can be overwhelming; the options are just endless.  Most times, we are faced with serious confusion, especially shoppers that prefer online stores to brick-and-mortar options. And this is because the former doesn’t offer the option of testing the mattresses out. 

When you compare the Tuft & Needle with the Leesa Mattress, you will discover a couple of similarities.  First off, they both have similar appearances, same ten-inch height, built with foam layers, and have similar prices.  However, a closer look at these two will reveal some differences that could determine whether not you get the comfortable sleep you desire.  We understand that discovering these differences on your own can be demanding. Thus we have done all the hard work for you.  

Here is a comprehensive review of both mattresses, with emphasis on what differentiates them.  Perhaps, we should start with the construction – the Tuft & Needle mattress spots a relatively simpler design with just two layers, while the Leesa Mattress has multiple foam layers, with an Avena foam corrugated layer the first of the layers.  So, if your preference is layers of specialty foam, the former is your best bet.  

We also discovered, through research, that Tuft and Needle Mattress comes handy for average weight sleepers, who will prefer a firmer mattress with zero sinking feeling.  Conversely, heavier sleepers or sleepers with pressure point issues will find Leesa mattress a more comfortable option, considering its design, which makes it adaptive for several body types.  In the same vein, side sleepers will find the Tuft and Needle mattress firmer, especially if they have below-average weights. The versatility of the Leesa mattress lies in its ability to support all styles of sleep, including side, stomach, or back sleeping.  It is also great for a hot-sleeper, all thanks to its construction.  

Enough of the introduction, let’s now take a closer look at the properties of each of these mattresses. 


Talking about the construction, both Leesa and Tuft & Needle opted for proprietary materials in building their mattresses.  Apparently, both manufacturers aimed at offering sleepers a cool sensation, and ultimately the maximum value for their money. 

Construction of the Leesa Mattress

Its construction is the first, and perhaps, the biggest impression the Leesa mattress will make.  At 10 inches of thickness, the mattress has a multilayered and high-quality construction.  The most important aspect of the construction is the proprietary Leesa’s proprietary foam – the Avena foam – used as the comforter top layer of the mattress.  Expect a closer look at this in the latter part of this review. 

Here is a closer look at the construction of the Leesa mattress:

The First Layer

As stated earlier, the first layer is the topmost layer, made with the proprietary Avena foam. At two-inch thickness, this foam offers some distinct features.  It feels just like latex – the most premium foam material any manufacturer could use in the industry – but it is relatively cheaper and more durable.  You can get maximum sleeping pleasure from this layer, irrespective of your sleeping position.  This is one of the several ways you get good value for your money with Leesa Mattress. 

The Second Layer

This layer is specifically designed to offer sleepers with excellent support while relieving pressure.  It works by helping you achieve the right spinal alignment through the stabilized feel it offers.  The two-inch thick second layer serves as the support layer and a transitional layer between the foundation and the top layer. 

The Third Layer

Here you have the foundation layer or the base of the mattress.  At six inches thick, the third layer is strong enough to serve as the foundation for the other two layers.  Amongst other things, it gives the much-needed shape and maintains the same, while offering adequate support for the other layers. 

Considering how much the mattress sells for, it is safe to say that you get a perfect combination of comfort and support with the Leesa Mattress.  The latex-like features of the first layer are not common in the current market, especially at this price.  You also have a cover carefully designed using a top-quality polyester and Lycra.  This combination offers great durability and protection.  

Construction of Tuft & Needle

Compared to the triple-layer design of Leesa, the Tuft & Needle mattress is constructed with two distinct layers and comes with ten inches of thickness.

The First Layer

The first layer is created from polyurethane foam with a PCF of 2.9. Ideally, this layer is designed to offer not only adequate support but also the convenience and cooling effect. In terms of thickness, it is three inches dense.

The Second Layer

The second layer is constructed from polyurethane foam with a PCF of 1.8. This layer is designed to serve as the mattress’s foundation; hence, it is expected to offer proper support and ensures that the spine is well-aligned.

Keep in mind that the foam which is being used in the mattress is proprietary and developed by Tuft & Needle. The foam is believed to offer top-quality features. It has a plain and snow-white cover which offers excellent protection. Also, the cover is designed in a way that it doesn’t obstruct the abilities of the mattress layers.

Comparing the Firmness

Choosing a mattress with the right feel for yourself is one of the fundamental means of selecting a bed. Besides, your mattress should serve as the perfect relaxation spot for you; a mattress that offers no comfort makes no sense.

Primarily, the firmness of a mattress, which is its level of hardness or softness, determines its comfort level. While shopping for mattresses, terms such as “soft,” “medium firm,” “plush” among others might be seen in different products. To enlighten you further about these terms, we have applied the firmness scale that ranks the firmness of a mattress between one and ten - where one stands for the softest and ten represents the hardest mattress.

Every individual has a specific preference regarding how a mattress should feel. Hence, comfort is entirely subjective. Generally, the majority of individuals prefer the medium-firm mattress that ranks between five and seven. However, some products are available that are significantly plusher or firmer.

In terms of firmness level, Tuft & Needle mattress and original Leesa mattress have a lot in common. On the traditional firmness scale, the two brands are believed to fall between six and seven. While the adaptive foam from Tuft & Needle is well-known for its slightly firmer feel compared to the Premium foam from Leesa, the comfort feel from both are largely similar.

Comparing the Sleep Experience

While comparing different mattress products, it is salient to think about firmness as well as other factors related to mattress performance. Here, we will distinguish between Tuft & Needle mattress and Leesa products in terms of some vital elements that can influence sleep experience.


A term which is used to explain the supportiveness of a mattress is referred to as responsiveness. A responsive mattress will offer a streamlined cushioning to the user’s body as it will compress more to accept the weighty side of the body like the pelvis or the shoulder. With such support, the mattress can help align the spine properly as well as prevent aches and pains most notably in the lower back region.

Between Tuft & Needle mattress and Leesa, the later has more responsiveness – but only slightly than the former. Regardless of the sleeper’s preferred position, both beds offer sufficient responsiveness to provide comfort and peaceful sleep experience – including the side sleepers that are likely to experience a pronounced pressure points.

Temperature Control

Several individuals loathe sleeping hot as it can make night sleep quite problematic for them. That aside, others feel very uncomfortable to wake up with sweat all over them. Consequently, temperature control is a vital factor to consider while shopping for a bed.

Usually, a lack of airflow around the body causes sleeping hot. This situation often occurs when the bed is pressed too close to the body. Additionally, the materials which are used to make some mattress can aggravate overheating as heat quickly get stuck in them (traditional memory foam is a good example).

Speaking of temperature control, both Tuft & Needle mattress and Leesa beds are beyond par in that regard. None of the two brands has heat retention or sink issues that characterizes the classic memory foams. With Tuft & Needle mattress, there is always enough room for air to flow since the mattress doesn’t hug the body excessively. Also, since Leesa offers more bounce and resilience, they can easily prevent excessive sinking into the mattress. Compared to the Tuft & Needle mattress, Leesa offers more contouring, which allows it to sleep a little bit hotter. However, only people who are concerned with sleeping hot can notice such a slight difference.

Motion Transfer

Both Tuft & Needle mattress and Leesa performs beyond average when it comes to motion isolation. Majority of Customers have no complaints regarding the motion which their partners felt while on the mattress together. Due to the extra bounce which Leesa offers, it may give more motion; however, generally, the two brands are excellent options for those who wish to experience adequate motion isolation.

Edge Support

Both Leesa and Tuft & Needle mattress may fail to offer enough support for those who use a more extended time sitting or lying down on the edges of their mattress. The two brands have weak edges, and since there is less foam to give support, the limits often feel like it will cave in when the weight falls on it. Also, none of the two brands produce a design which offer reinforcement to the limits in a bid to solve the trouble. If one of your most essential needs from a mattress is edge support, then, in this aspect, none of the two mattresses is your best options.

Resilience and Bounce

A resilient mattress is a bed that returns to its actual shape once the applied pressure is removed and offers a bouncy feel. Some sleepers prefer resilient cushions since moving on such a bed is usually easier. This feature can be particularly useful to prevent the “stuck” feeling and can come handy for sexual performance.

Premium Foam from Leesa comes with a design that offers extra bounce with a feel similar to the latex mattress. Likewise, Tuft & Needle mattress is above par when it comes to resilience. Hence, despite the fact that Leesa offers more resilience, several Customers are satisfied with the bounce which Tuft & Needle mattress offers.

Off-gassing and Odors

Once a mattress is unpacked, the most likely situation is to perceive a smell that comes from the decompressing foam. This scent is not hazardous and would leave within a few hours. Both Leesa and Tuft & Needle mattress will probably release such smell.

Comparing the Prices

Currently, compared to the other mattresses in the market, the Tuft & Needle mattress offers the best value. Even though some products are cheaper, however, in terms of a track record of satisfied customers and attention-to-detail designs, the Tuft & Needle mattress leads the pack. Also, Tuft & Needle mattress offers one of the best bargains if you are much concerned about price.

Nevertheless, Leesa also offers exceptional value. Sometimes, you can even pay a lesser price compared to those listed via discounts or promotions given by the company. Compared to several other foam mattresses, Leesa has more affordability. And also, speaking of a proven track record of satisfied Customers, Leesa products are up there with the best – and consequently, most people see it as a product worth the price.

Comparing the Return Policy, Sleep Trial, and Warranty

Leesa offers 100 nights of sleep trial period, and so does Tuft & Needle mattress. However, Leesa’s offer includes that to place a return for request, a bed should have been used for the first thirty days since it is seen as the optimal number of nights in which the user would need to get used to the feel of the new bed and determine whether it fits their need or not. As for Tuft & Needle mattress, there is no mandatory trial period as Customers can return mattress at any time. But, take note that customers who have purchased their beds from Tuft & Needle mattress official website or Huckberry are the only ones that are eligible to the 100-night sleep trial. Hence, buyers who made their purchase from third-party retailers are not eligible for the 100-night sleep trial.

At Leesa, the company offers free delivery, but old mattress removal or white glove delivery are offered at extra cost. Also, aside from Customers residing in Alaska and Hawaii, all other returns are free. Furthermore, Tuft & Needle mattress offers no refund for shipping cost for returns coming from Hawaii and Alaska.

Although Leesa offers 10-year warranty, the claim will become invalid once they discover that the bed was not used with the right foundation. Leesa’s warranty includes 1-inch or deeper indentations and issues such as cover zipper or seams; however, it does not cover sagging below 1-inch, repairs, and replacement based on sleeper’s change of preference as well as cuts, stains, or any accidental damages.

Any shipping between three to seven days are covered by Tuft & Needle mattress, but, they allow same-day shipping for some locations at extra cost. Customers dwelling in Hawaii and Alaska will need to pay for extra shipping cost. Tuft & Needle mattress warranty will become invalid in the absence of the right foundation support for the mattress. Also, the policy of their warranty supports sagging or indentation, which are ¾ of an inch or more, manufacturing defects, bed flaws that damaged the foam, as well as cover zippers and seams. However, their warranty does not cover sagging below ¾ of an inch, burns, stains or any damage caused by neglect or misuse. 

Which is the better choice; Tuft & Needle Mattress vs. Leesa Mattress?

Choosing a brand between two reputable companies like Leesa and Tuft & Needle mattress can be quite challenging since there are several considerations to make and justify in the process. However, in this section, we will be sharing some distinct difference between the two brands that can guide your decision-making to choose the best mattress for yourself.

You are better off with Leesa Mattress if:

You are overweight: Leesa mattresses can be particularly handy for those that weigh beyond 230 pounds as they offer proper cushioning to the joints and the pressure points. This mattress comes with a solid layer, which ensures that it is supportive and firm. Also, the memory foams bit in the center, and the adaptive Avena foam top layer enables this bed to offer some plush cushioning without being incredibly soft. Weighty individuals are more likely to sink excessively into softer bed and consequently, sleep hot. However, Leesa mattress is rated as a medium-firm bed, comfortable and offers a floating-on-top feeling.

You are a hot sleeper: compared to the tricky materials which some brands use in their mattresses, the Avena foam's corrugated on the top of Leesa beds offer something extraordinary. Within the corrugated layer are air pockets which enhance airflow and ensures that the mattress stays cool. Also, with such layers above the memory foam layer, Customers won’t sink excessively into the bed while those who are susceptible to sleeping hot will relish a cool and dry sleep. Several Customers who naturally sleep hot has given excellent feedback about this mattress.

You fancy a bit of memory foam but not too much: Leesa mattress is the solution for those who love the soft cushy feeling of memory foam but loathe getting “stuck” in their bed. With the two inches of memory foam in Leesa mattress, the bed can cushion the body without being incredibly soft. Customers always relish how the mattress perfectly adapts to their body shape, offer support and firmness, and yet feels soft on shoulders, hips, and other joint areas.

Leesa mattress is a ten-inch tall foam mattress and contains three layers. High-density support foam of about six inches is used to develop the base layer. This construction leads to the low motion transfer which the bed offer as well as the stable and firm base for the upper layers.

Leesa mattress is ideal for light sleepers or those who sleep with partners that often turn and roll. A two-inch memory foam layer is placed above the base layer. This layer offers softness that gives a wonderful slumber experience for different sleeping positions.

You are better off with a Tuft & Needle Mattress if:

You are of average weight: Although Tuft & Needle Mattress often satisfy the need of all kinds of the body; however, the average-sized Customers seem to be the most comfortable among them. A small number of Customers who are stomach sleepers and weighty have stated that it took them some time to get used to their mattress while a few who are side sleepers had to buy an extra topper to relieve pressure points caused by the mattress firmness against their excess body weight.

However, the majority of customers with different body types found the mattress performance to be satisfying.

You are a hot sleeper: Sleepers who tend to sleep hot have declared that they are satisfied with this product as they don’t get “stuck” in the mattress compared to their experience with soft memory foam. This is possible due to the firmness of Tuft & Needle mattress. Hence, if you are susceptible to sleeping hot, this mattress may be the best option for you, most especially if you are a big fan of firmer beds.

You want a mattress with a simple construction: Mattress with basic construction often saves you funds. This mattress comes with two simple layers and a few frills. While high-density foam has a top layer that is proprietary, this bed has a simple design. If you have great concerns against technical foams and those with several layers, then this mattress is your ideal option as it is made with simple foam and plain. Also, it is free of memory foam.

You don’t want to spend much: anyone will find it hard to beat the cost of Tuft & Needle mattress in relation to the level of customer satisfaction which it offers. Aside from the relatively affordable cost of this mattress, the company provides an excellent warranty as well as a sleep trial period. When you consider all these advantages coupled with exceptional customer service, which makes several customers feel on top of the world, you are likely to see no better than option this bed.

Similar to Leesa mattress, the Tuft & Needle mattress begins with base layer foam of high density, which makes it an excellent choice for those who have reservations against motion transfer. Also, the base layer offers reliable stability and support, which ensures that one partner does not wake another as well as prevent them from rolling into the middle. Nevertheless, compared to the 6-inch thick base layer of Leesa mattress, Tuft & Needle mattress comes with a base layer that is seven inches thick. Over the base layer is another high density layer of 3-inch deep which is referred to as the T&N Adaptive foam. This foam is developed to conform as well as remain cool.

Final Words

Your budget and personal preference will go a long way in determining your preference between Tuft & Needle and Leesa Mattress.  Talking about firmness, you get medium firmness from both options, although the Tuft and Needle options are said to be a bit firmer.

If you have a thing for memory foam and the cushiness it offers, then you would be interested in Leesa mattress because they contain a bit of it. The thicker base lovers will prefer the Tuft and Needle mattress, considering its thicker base layer of foam and fewer top layers.  This arrangement contributes to a simpler, but sturdier, build.  A couple of heavier sleepers believe that the Tuft and Needle mattress offers a bit too much firmness, especially the stomach and side heavier sleepers.  

Generally, there have been great and positive feedbacks on both mattresses, irrespective of the body size of the sleepers, although the Tuft and Needle bed recorded slightly higher sales compared to the Leesa.  The two options have decent cooling features, after all, they are slightly firm, and the ‘sinking’ effect is not pronounced.  The top layers of foam in the two types of mattresses are designed to offer coolness, and most customers have testified to this.  However, there are a few feedback that suggests that sleepers get hot when using either of both. 

Talking about warranty and sleep trial, both mattresses have these options.  The Leesa sells for about 200-300 USD, although the price may be unstable considering the periodic promotions and discounts that come with the Leesa products.  

Conclusively, Tuft and Needle beds will be best for sleepers looking to get a firmer bed at a relatively lower price, while the Leesa Mattress is great for sleepers with a preference for the memory foam feel, irrespective of their body weight or preferred sleeping position. Protection Status 


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.