The research done on this website is made possible by commissions earned through sales from affiliate links shared within the content. Learn more here.
Pillow tops are considered a luxurious type of mattresses. With the presence of an additional upholstery layer, pillow tops offer more comfort and a great appearance. And in this piece, we will be discussing the top pillow mattresses you can find in the market currently.
The comfort offered by pillow top mattresses is due to the presence of soft upholstery, and the effect lasts for the first few months. In addition to comfort, pillow top mattresses prevent joint pain and also reduce pressure points by ensuring that your body weight is spread more evenly. Although this comfort level is expected to last for as long as possible, most pillow top mattresses end up losing this feature after a few months. Thus, when getting a pillow top mattress, getting one that will stand the test of time is very important. Apart from serving as expected, it saves you the cost of getting a replacement sooner than you have ever expected.
This guide offers insight into a couple of pillow top mattresses - especially reviews and buyer’s guide. Although we reviewed all the pillow top mattresses we could lay our hands on, below are the top seven options out of the pack. You will definitely find one that suits your needs out of these top seven pillow mattresses discussed below.
Best Pillow Top Mattress Products
1. Sleep Inc. - The Best Innerspring Pillow Top Mattress
2. Mattress America - The Best Pillow Top Mattress For The Money
3. Signature Sleep - The Best Hybrid Coil Pillow Top Mattress
4. Classic Brands "Mercer"- The Best Hybrid Pillow Top Mattress
5. Classic Brands - The Best Cool Gel Pillow Top Mattress
6. Sertapedic - The Best Luxurious Pillow Top Mattress
Best Pillow Top Mattress Brands and Products Table
Best Pillow Top Mattress Brands and Products Reviews
Complete Comfort 600 Pillow Top Mattress by Sleep Inc.
Rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars
Customer satisfaction: 100%
Dimension: 59 x 79 x 12 inches
Thickness: 12 Inches
Weight: 56 pounds
According to the manufacturer, Sleep Inc., the comfort pillow top mattress offers a perfect blend of soft coziness and durability. It is made for individuals interested in medium to plus comfort level in their bed.
There are two separate segments of the mattress – the top and bottom tiers. The bottom tier is made up of several innerspring coils, while the top tier has layers of foam materials. And with the support and comfort provided by this pillow, you are sure to get a good night’s rest. Handcrafted in the USA, this pillow comes with an amazing 10-year limited warranty – a nine-year prorated warranty and a one-year non-prorated warranty.
Support and Comfort
The luxury and relaxing experience you get from this pillow is top-notch. The presence of the foam and innerspring layers means that the product will not compress easily, even after extensive use. Although the innerspring design prevents sagging, it is recommended that you rotate this pillow top mattress at a couple of months’ interval. This ensures that the shape is not lost.
You may perceive some chemical-like odor when unboxing for the first time. So, it is best that you place the pillow in an open-air place where the fresh air can neutralize the smell. You may also have to wait for a week to inflate and expand the mattress to the maximum size. To get the best out of this product regarding comfort, you would have to break it in. To get the maximum comfort level, sleep on it for a couple of months and rotate it at fixed intervals.
There is a clear 360-degree foam encasement, which enhances the edge support and ensures that the surface remains firm even when someone sits on the edge of the mattress.
Customer Feedback About The Complete Comfort 600 Pillow Top Mattress
360-degree foam encasement
10-year limited warranty
The presence of innerspring layers
Remove turning, tossing, and movement sensations
Requires airing out
Inflation to full size takes a considerable amount of time, and rotation is required to maintain the best shape
Frost Hybrid Pocket Coil Pillow Top Mattress by Mattress America
Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
Customer satisfaction: 88%
Dimension: 80 x 13 x 60 inches
Thickness: 13 Inches
Weight: 90 pounds
Over time, Mattress America has come to understand the yearnings of their customers even better. The company has combined top features that are in high demand by customers in their Frost Pocket Pillow Top Mattress, making it a popular choice among buyers.
At 13 inches length and 3 inches thickness, the foam materials in this pillow are very much comfortable and rest on a pocket coil core of 10 inches. There is gel-infused memory foam in the foam tier, which provides a luxurious feel, while the innerspring tier offers sturdiness and improved support quotient.
Interestingly, this product comes with 25 years warranty, giving you a double re-assurance of its quality, build, and its ability to stand the test of time.
Support and Comfort
There is a separate encased coil structure which distributes the pillow’s firmness and supports evenly throughout its surface. Thus, you can use it in improving your lumbar and back support; to achieve quality rest; or for movement cancellation. However, this soft cloud-like sink in the mattress may not be suitable for side-sleepers, because the hard surface hardly curves perfectly around the body.
The odorless nature of this pillow top mattress means that you do not have to wait for airing before using it. Full inflation and expansion, however, takes two weeks so it may not fill up the king bed box immediately.
The mattress comes with a durable and soft cover. Your body will remain relaxed and free of sweat with this product because it is breathable. As evident in CertiPUR-US certificate, this product is made from eco-friendly materials and free of any harmful chemicals or substances.
Customer Feedback About The Frost Hybrid Pocket Coil Pillow Top Mattress
Good for back sleepers due to its considerable firmness
Breathable top layer
Takes time to inflate
Too firm for side sleepers
Signature Sleep Hybrid Coil Mattress
Rating: 4.4 out of 5 stars
Customer satisfaction: 87%
Dimension: 80 x 60 x 13 inches
Thickness: 13 Inches
Weight: 93.5 pounds
Signature Sleep understands the diversification in the sleeping needs of individuals. Thus, over time, the brand has provided various products that meet the specific yet different customer preferences.
This pillow top mattress from Signature is made for individuals seeking a peaceful sleep without having to turn or toss.
Three layers of comfortable foam materials, including 10-inch thick innerspring coils, are all packed inside this 13-inch mattress. Both the firm bottom and the soft upper tier offers a combined comfort for certain essential body parts, including the hip, lower back, and the lower body.
There is also a durable and bamboo-fabric cover, and this eco-friendly and super breathable mattress is good at absorbing moisture, thus ensuring a restful and dry night’s rest.
Support and Comfort
To balance softness and firmness, this pillow offers 3-inch layers of foam materials that cradle your lower and upper body, as well as a 10-inch bottom layer that provides a durable surface to align your body. The coil design, which is encased separately, removes motion transfer so that your peaceful sleep is not disturbed by your partner’s movement.
The foam layer is not entirely rigid – it sinks when necessary to perfectly curve around your body. The thickness of this mattress can conveniently support the body, even when placed in an empty bed box. This eliminates the need for a box spring.
In addition to being certified by CertiPUR-US, this mattress has only trace amounts of volatile organic compounds – VOC. Likewise, it is free of ozone, lead, mercury, formaldehyde, and other heavy metal elements which are harmful to the body.
Customer Feedback About The Signature Sleep Hybrid Coil Mattress
A perfect blend of firmness and softness Requires no separate spring box
Might be too soft for some users
Airing out is required to off-gas
Mercer Pillow Top Cool Gel Hybrid Mattress by Classic Brands
Rating: 4.4 out of 5 stars
Customer satisfaction: 87%
Dimension: 80 x 60 x 12 inches
Thickness: 12 Inches
Weight: 93 pounds
The Classic Brands bedding items are the ideal options when seeking quality products at reasonable budgets. And as expected, their pillow top mattresses come at affordable rates compared to other brands.
There are five tiers in this 12-inch pillow top mattress. The top layer comprises of half-inch gel memory foam, under which there are sections of comfort foam, wrapped coils, and fiber. These unique sequences of materials ensure that the mattress stands the test of time. And with a 10-year warranty, customers can be guaranteed of getting maximum value for their money.
Support and Comfort
When you unbox this mattress, there is usually an offensive plastic-like smell. Thus, you need to off-gas it to reduce its intensity after a few days and eventual removal after a week. It takes a while for the mattress to break in, and getting the best performance may require sleeping on it for a long time.
You have a medium-firm surface, considering the presence of the evenly spread innerspring coils and the hybrid memory foam. When used extensively over time, the foam softens, however, the bottom layer retains its sturdiness while offering a lot of support.
The hypoallergenic gel foam present in the top tier ensures that the pillow does not accumulate dust, bacteria, allergens, or mold, making it entirely safe for use.
You also get a quilted pillow top knit sleeve, which is the cover of the mattress. This cover has been carefully sewn and comes with corded edges and sewn sides. The pillow is breathable, courtesy of the netted fabric. It is certified fit by the CertiPUR-US. Thus the polyurethane foam has been tested to be safe, durable, and offer maximum performance.
Customer Feedback About The Mercer Pillow Top Cool Gel Hybrid Mattress
A top layer made up of memory gel foam
The presence of innerspring coils for firm support
Takes a while to break in
Releases plastic-like smell for few hours after unboxing
Classic Brands Ultimate Gel Memory Foam Pillow Top Mattress
Rating: 4.3 out of 5 stars
Customer satisfaction: 84%
Dimension: 80 x 60 x 14 inches
Thickness: 14 Inches
Weight: 85.1 pounds
This Cool Gel Pillow from Classic Brands offers innovation, quality, and more importantly, the relaxation that everyone deserves during a night rest.
At 14-inch thickness, this king size mattress offers several layers of foam materials, all of top quality. The medium plush firmness ensures that customers can finally enjoy a bed that is neither too soft nor too hard. And interestingly, it can be paired with a bed frame with an adjustable base.
Over the years, Classic Brands have released products that have stood the test of time even after several years of use. And with this particular product, you get an extra assurance of excellence with a 25-year warranty.
Support and Comfort
The mattress comprises four different tiers of materials all expertly combined to ensure users have a loving sleeping companion that solves most of their sleep problems. The ventilated gel foam, the soft comfort foam, the memory foam, and the high-density polo base foam all offer great individual, and their combination ensures that your body is always rested at the right posture when you take that deep night’s rest. The mattress comes with an 8-inch thick base, which contours the body shape while relieving pressure points. You can rest assured of no sweats or early morning neck, shoulder, or hip pains.
The internal layers of this gorgeous pillow are held together firmly, courtesy of the stretch knit fabric cover, which also comes with a waterfall edge. The product is CertiPUR-US certified and comes with two memory foam pillows.
Customer Feedback About The Classic Brands Ultimate Gel Pillow Top Mattress
Four-tier foam materials
A high-density base that offers excellent support
Materials have allergen-resistant features
Unpleasant odor at the early stages of usage
It takes time to fit into a queen bed frame
Super Pillow Top 300 Innerspring Mattress by Sertapedic
Rating: 4.4 out of 5 stars
Customer satisfaction: 95%
Dimension: 80 x 60 x 12.2 inches
Thickness: 14 Inches
Weight: 60 pounds
If you are on the lookout for a perfect pillow top mattress that outrightly complements your king-size bed, this Sertapedic Super Pillow is just right for you, with its enhanced and breathable comfort.
At 12-inch thickness, this mattress offers to everyone a perfect blend of softness and support. You can make a complete set by combining it with a platform bed, or two California King Size foundations.
There are four sections in this mattress – tree of the layers, at the top, have foam materials, while the fourth and the bottom segment is packed with innerspring coils and foam encasement. The design of the coil gauge ensures that the pillow provides a firmer feel across the mattress.
While you may have to contend with the excessive off-gassing at first, keeping the pillow in an airy place for a few days will get rid of the last of the chemical stench. With Serta, you are assured of extra peace of mind – the mattress comes with a 5-year warranty.
Support and Comfort
This product provides excellent firmness and softness, with the firmness a bit more pronounced due to the presence of the gel foam. The cells within the gel foam have higher porosity compared to the conventional foams. Thus, air passes through quickly, and in turn, the foam regulates the temperature across the whole surface. There is a padded section that offers comfort, and the magical adjustment feature of the pillow is due to the presence of the innerspring part. The innerspring part also ensures that your spine maintains its ideal position. The sensation of motion is significantly reduced with the pillow, all thanks to the spring segment.
The Sertapedic Super Pillowtop sports a separately wrapped coil innerspring alongside an edge foam encasement. This exquisite design means the pillow offers a unified appearance plus a sturdy seating surface. The product is built and designed in the USA and is certified by the CertiPUR-US in confirmation of its high-quality performance.
Customer Feedback About The Super Pillow Top 300 Innerspring Mattress by Sertapedic
3-tier foam materials, each tier offering support and comfort
Certified by CertiPUR-US
It is a bit on the high side
Introducing a Pillow Top Mattress
Pillow Top Mattresses are generally made with a comfortable layer of padding, almost like that of a pillow. However, this layer of padding either rests on the whole mattress surface and sometimes underneath it. This arrangement allows for a two-sided facility. A pillow top mattress is a good means of adding an extra comfort layer to a mattress.
There are a couple of style options to choose from, and they come in diverse materials, including fiber, memory foam, and latex. Interestingly, pillow top mattresses can be customized to taste, for example, by replacing the layer to something firmer or softer. So, if you ever find the current layer too firm for you, you can replace the top only, instead of getting another whole unit.
Comparing the EuroTop and the Pillow Top
The difference here is simple – the Eurotop is attached to the mattress and thus becomes a part of the whole sleeping surface. Conversely, the pillow-top lies independently on the bed and is not entirely a part of the sleeping surface. The pillow top may be attached via zips or straps.
Eurotop is more preferred among most people because it offers a more aesthetic appearance with the mattress being in one piece. Most times, the Eurotop is made from materials of high quality, and this contributes to its expensiveness. However, even with the increased price, the Eurotop is not as versatile in its functionality. The reduced versatility is because there is a single sleeping surface available and the added layer is fixed and irremovable. Conversely, the pillow top can be changed easily if you have a new partner or there is a change in your sleeping habit.
Pros and Cons of Using Pillow Top Mattress
The main benefit a pillow top mattress offers is the extensive comfort. Like a regular pillow or cushion, pillow-top mattresses have varying degrees of firmness, and this is the main contributing factor to the excellent comfort they offer. However, most types of pillow top mattresses in the market today are designed for individuals interested in a medium or soft finish.
You will get all the comfort available in memory foam or hybrid option in a pillow top mattress, but for a lower price. Pillow top mattresses, like hybrids, are packed with many layers, and this is their unique advantage over other mattress types.
Cost is another advantage of pillow top mattresses. Getting a memory foam mattress separately will cost far more, whereas, a pillow top mattress offers the same benefits at a lower price.
Pillow top mattresses can suit many sleeping positions. Thus, several side sleepers and back sleepers enjoy maximum comfort throughout the night, all thanks to the contouring and conforming abilities of the top layer of pillow top mattresses. This layer ensures that the spine is well aligned, although it is not a direct replacement for orthopedic mattresses when it comes to lower back pain correction.
Pillow top mattresses also offer good motion isolation – they constitute most of the better designs in the industry that offers superior isolation of movement. Thus, using a pillow top mattress ensures that one user is not disturbed by the turning and tossing of another user besides them. Motion isolation in pillowtop mattresses is due to the presence of pocket coil designs, and the ability of the thick layer to absorb the energy produced from movement before they reach the coils.
The last on the list of the advantages of pillow top mattress is its suitability for couples. Couples will most likely enjoy sex on this type of bed, considering the added sensation that comes with laying on a cloud from the plush and sometimes padded top layer. The spring coils underneath these mattresses also ensure that there is enough bounce to keep it going.
Having discussed the strength of the pillow top mattresses, discussing the weakness is necessary, to achieve a balance. This will help you to make the right decision and ensure you get good value for your money. Here are the cons of the pillow top.
With the presence of the additional quilting and material, there is an increased possibility of an elevated warmth under the covers. The way out of this is to choose materials that breathe more and with optimal airflow.
They are usually thicker, considering the innerspring design. It may be difficult to find a perfect matching fitted-sheet for your pillow top.
Higher chances of surface indentations
The uplift and surface responsiveness in lesser quality materials are not as pronounced as in top quality materials. Thus, getting a superior material like natural latex or memory foam will be a better investment option.
Pillow top, sometimes, is far too soft.
Available Materials to Choose From
There are two forms of latex – synthetic and organic latex.
The organic latex is gotten from trees through the Dunlop process. This type of latex are usually eco-friendly and are healthy solutions for your mattress topper. However, you must take avoid any natural rubber allergies.
The synthetic latex is made from petroleum substances with anti-microbial and hypoallergenic properties. It is cheaper and comes in different grades. Thus, it is essential that you get your synthetic latex pillow top from a trusted brand that builds them from top-grade materials.
Latex is known to be very durable, although it is expensive if it is the unadulterated type. When you consider how long and well it serves, the high price is worth it.
This is the cheapest foam type in the market, and the products made from them are usually of less durability, especially if the density is too low. Always get a polyurethane product that has a density level above five.
Polyurethane foam is also petroleum-based, as in synthetic latex. However, the volatile organic compounds that constitute this substance are more susceptible to off-gas compared to organic materials.
If you do not plan to spend much on getting a pillow top, you may consider a polyurethane pillow top. However, ensure that the manufacturer uses only safe and eco-friendly flame-retardants during the build.
Also known as fiberfill, polyester is mostly used as padding for pillow-tops. The greatest strength of this material is its price – it is lesser in cost compared to wool, natural cotton, and organic latex. It should be noted that polyester is not inferior in quality to naturally-sourced elements. Instead, there are higher-class fiberfill polyester is very much superior and offers the same super soft and comfy feeling when laid on.
An added advantage of the polyester is its easy-to-clean feature. It can be washed in the washing machine.
Another name for viscoelastic foam is memory foam beds. Generally referred to as the most advanced material when it comes to technological advancement, the NASA created the viscoelastic foam for the use of their astronauts. The distinguishing feature, then, was its ability to reduce pressure to the physique when the shuttle takes off.
One great thing about viscoelastic foam is its ability to contour to the natural shape of the body with so much ease. You may not enjoy the same level of cradling you get on a pillow top made from a viscoelastic foam from somewhere else.
A downside of the memory foam is that it sleeps hot because the sleeping surface retains heat. However, the effect is significantly reduced in products blended with gel or copper or with a cell structure.
Choosing The Best Pillow Top Mattress
There are certain factors to consider when choosing a pillow top mattress for your use. These points are discussed below:
Several materials are used in making pillow top mattresses. While the support section may be a combination of both springs and foam, and in some cases, either of the two. Most times, the pillow layer is made from memory foam or latex, although polyester may also be used for cheaper products.
What determines the overall comfort is the type and quality of the pillow layer. While memory foam has the ability to contour to the body shape naturally and offer great support in the process, natural latex is also known to offer a responsive sleeping surface which ensures that there is only minimum pressure on a particular area. Latex does not get hot like other regular foams. Polyester, although the lowest quality option, offers a sleeping surface with considerable comfort.
The structural properties of the mattress depending on the materials used in building the support section. While you can get good support from spring mattresses, they may also transmit movement more than foam support layers. And if you are looking for a perfect blend of comfort and support, support foam is the best option.
How long the product will last also depends on the materials used in making them. Latex models last longest and cost most. You will also get a considerably extended period of use from dense memory foam, and it hardly deforms permanently compared to other cheaper materials.
The level of firmness each mattress offer is different. When compared to the tight top mattress, the design of pillow tops makes them generally softer than other materials. Even with this, there are still some differences in the level of comfort.
Your sleeping position and personal preference will determine the level of firmness you would prefer. If you are the type that likes sleeping on your side, you would be better off with a softer choice as such a product will help you to sink further down into the mattress. If you usually sleep on your stomach, you should get a firmer option – medium-firm pillow top mattress. This option ensures that your body maintains its neutral position while sleeping.
Always choose a product with a firmness level that corresponds to the style and position of sleep you’ve adopted.
One downside of settling for an item with too much thickness is that you may not find the corresponding fitted-sheet. When you lay thicker layers on your mattress, you have a softer and more supportive feel. It’s even better if you are a bit heavier.
The average thickness of common pillow tops is about two inches. And this offers adequate relief from pressure and support. You would only require something thicker, perhaps about four inches thickness, if you want to revamp your old bed.
Considering the level of financial commitment that goes into getting a mattress, taking the time to choose the right one is very important. You should consider which features you prioritize above others, and watch out for them in your potential options. You can check mattress reviews to find which sports most of your preferences.
Below are some extra factors that you should consider when making your choice of a mattress.
Price is a crucial factor in the process of getting a mattress. The current market provides several options for mattresses with various prices. You may not spend much on temporary alternatives like a mattress topper. The same cannot be said when getting a pillow top mattress. However, there are certain features of the pillow top mattress that is absent in a mattress topper.
It is best to consider the purchase of a new mattress as an investment in your quality of sleep, and getting it wrong can impact your overall health adversely.
Most people are of the belief that a pillow top has just one component – this is wrong. There are a couple of layers underneath, and the pillow top may only refer to the uppermost layer of the mattress. The level of comfort a pillow top offers depends on the components making up the underneath. Thus, when on the lookout for a new mattress, you should settle for materials that match your preferences in a mattress.
Most times, the options you are provided with combines several layers in different ways, with each layer offering various benefits. For instance, you may find a variation of innerspring and viscoelastic memory foam, or with the inclusion of a gel foam as well.
If you are the type that sleeps hot, you must get a bed that has cooling elements infused in it. Your quality of sleep will be adversely affected if you end up getting too hot at night. To avoid this, you should look at products made from such materials like latex gel, gel foam, copper-infused foam, cell structures, innerspring technology, and grids. Such products are great for sleeping cool and refreshed. You may also consider wool and cotton – they both offer perfect airflow when present in a pillow top by wicking away moisture and heat perfectly.
The Outer Layer Material is another important point to consider. Do not go for pure-play memory foams – they are notorious for storing heat.
Motion Transfer and Isolation
If you are the type that is sensitive to even the slightest motion on your bed while sleeping, you change your bed. Most old beds are known to transmit constant vibration and motion, and this is due to the loss of the tension present in the innerspring. While changing your entire unit may be an expensive option, you can just add a high pillow top instead. With a pillow top, you get improved performance from the whole sleeping surface of your bed.
Befitting materials for this type of role include latex and better quality memory foams. You may also consider thicker wools and fiberfill. Note that using the pillow top helps your mattress surface to isolate movement via pinpointed and precision-based rapid adaptation of the surface without rippling.
Always check the brand reviews to get a clearer picture of what materials are present in each product before making a choice.
The CertiPUR-US program involves all the companies represented by the products reviewed. As the watchdog of the foam industry, this program offers strong assurance to buyers of mattresses that the components are free of any harmful materials or chemicals. Thus, the program checks each product and verifies that it adheres to their standards before releasing them into the market. Another function of the program is in the regulation of durability and performance to assure consumers of the best quality possible.
The extent of warranties in foam products vary – you get ten years from some manufacturers and 25 from others. While the extent is not important, it is better to go for a product with at least ten years warranty. After all, no one is likely keeping a mattress for more than ten years.
Frequently Asked Questions
What causes the increased temperature in my mattress?
The material is probably the culprit here. The absence of adequate thermal regulation can lead to several complaints about pillow-top mattresses, especially those products made of regular foam or conventional high-density memory foam. These materials cannot dissipate heat efficiently, so they store it instead, making the night disturbingly hot for you.
How can I remove lumps in my pillow-top kind of bed?
One way of mitigating the adverse effects of this is to get a pillow-top as part of the building materials. Latex prevents lumps, likewise any pillow top brand that is well built. Another alternative is to try to distribute the lump evenly throughout the cover. This is relatively easier, and you only need to apply the progressive movements of your hands. If this does not fix the problem, you may consider exercising your warranty rights.
There are hardly mattress types that offer more softness or comfort than pillow tops. Although there may be issues with their durability and life expectancy, as well as the inability to turn them when they start to sag, pillow tops are still great options for excellent comfort. While these downsides are undeniable, these products offer great benefits as well, including reducing joint pains and minimizing movement transmission (depending on the layer materials).
When buying a pillow top mattress, the first and most important factor to consider is the kinds of material that make up the comfort and the support layer. After this, you should look at your budget and how firm the mattress is. Although the best choice will eventually depend on your personal preferences and your sleeping position, you may also need to look at the life expectancy of the mattress.
If all these factors are considered, you will find it easy to settle for a pillow top mattress product that suits your needs.
You May Also Be Interested in the Next Posts on Our Website: